Skip to content

Early Black Friday: up to 40% off · See plans

All guides

Guide

BMI vs ASCAP: costs, contracts and how each one pays

BMI and ASCAP do the same job. They license public performances of songs and pay the writers and publishers. Both are free for songwriters, and you can only join one as a writer, so the choice comes down to the details: publisher fees, how the contracts end and when the money arrives. Everything below comes from their own pages, checked on 22 November 2026.

Updated November 22, 2026

Short answer

BMI and ASCAP are both free to join as a songwriter, and both collect US performance royalties for songwriters and publishers. The biggest differences are in the paperwork. BMI charges publishers a one-time $175 to $500 and its writer agreement renews in two-year terms. ASCAP charges $50 for a publisher-only membership, waives it if you join as writer and publisher together, and lets you resign in a window every two years. You can belong to only one as a writer.

What to do, in order

  1. Check you're not already a member

    You can belong to only one PRO at a time as a writer. If you joined one years ago, log in there first. ASCAP says to contact your current society to switch.

  2. Decide on a publisher membership

    If you haven't signed a publishing deal, set up your own publisher membership so you can collect the publisher's half of performance royalties. Compare the publisher fees in the table.

  3. Have your ID and tax details ready

    ASCAP asks every applicant for a government-issued ID and a live photo check. BMI asks writers under 18 for a custodial trust account at a US bank.

  4. Register your songs straight away

    Joining doesn't register your catalog. Add every song, with co-writers and shares, as soon as your membership is active.

  5. Note your exit dates

    Write down when your BMI term ends or when your ASCAP resignation window opens. Missing it can tie you in for two more years.

BMI vs ASCAP at a glance

These are the details each organization publishes. BMI's writer agreement leaves the first term's dates blank, so check the dates on your own contract.

DetailBMIASCAP
Cost for songwritersFree, no annual duesFree
Cost for publishersOne time: $175 individual, $250 corporation or LLC, $500 partnershipOne time: $50 if you join only as a publisher, waived if you join as writer and publisher together
Who can join as a writerSongwriters and composersAnyone who wrote or co-wrote at least one work available to the public
Contract and leavingRenews in two-year terms; give notice 3 to 6 months before a term endsResign in a three-month window every two years, set by your join date
How often it paysQuarterly12 distributions a year: four domestic for writers, four domestic for publishers, four international
Time to paymentAbout five months after each quarter ends, going by its published datesDomestic royalties usually 6 to 9 months after a performance
Late claimsTell BMI within nine months of a distributionUp to one survey year retroactively
Size and structureMore than 1.5 million songwriters, composers and publishersMore than 1.1 million songwriters, composers and publishers; not-for-profit

From BMI's and ASCAP's own pages and BMI's standard writer agreement, checked on 22 November 2026. BMI's timing is based on its published payment dates.

What a PRO does

A performing rights organization licenses businesses that play music in public, such as radio, TV, venues, bars, shops and streaming services. It tracks or surveys what was played and pays the writers and publishers of those songs.

A PRO pays for the song, not the recording. It doesn't replace The MLC for US streaming mechanicals or SoundExchange for digital radio, so join those too.

Every type of music royalty explained

How much it costs to join

BMI says joining as a songwriter or composer is free, with no fees or annual dues of any kind. Setting up a publishing company with BMI costs a one-time $175 for an individual, $250 for a corporation or LLC and $500 for a partnership. That fee isn't refundable or deductible from future earnings.

ASCAP is free for new writer members. If you join as both writer and publisher at the same time, it waives both application fees, which it describes as a temporary policy. Joining only as a publisher costs a one-time, non-refundable $50.

Contract terms and how to leave

BMI's standard writer agreement runs for an initial term, then keeps renewing for two years at a time. Either side can end it at the end of a term, with notice sent by a tracked method no more than six months and no less than three months before the term ends. BMI can keep licensing your songs under licenses already in place after you leave.

ASCAP lets you resign during a three-month notification window that comes round every two years, based on when you were elected a member. You resign through Member Access. If you miss the window, you wait two more years. When you go, you choose whether ASCAP keeps licensing your existing songs or moves them to your new PRO.

This is general information, not legal advice. Read your own agreement, and ask a music lawyer if you're switching with a large catalog.

How BMI and ASCAP pay

BMI pays quarterly. Its own schedule shows the payment on 20 November 2026 covering performances from the second quarter of 2026, and the next on 19 February 2027 covering the third quarter.

ASCAP makes 12 distributions a year, one each month, split between writers, publishers and international money. It says domestic royalties usually arrive 6 to 9 months after a performance, and it pays on a follow-the-dollar basis, so money from radio goes to radio performances and money from TV goes to TV.

For radio, ASCAP relies on a detection service and asks you or your distributor to upload your audio to Mediabase. It says it generally doesn't pay retroactively for music uploaded after the performance.

SESAC and GMR

The US has two more PROs. SESAC says it's invitation-only: the best route is for a lawyer, manager or agent to contact it for you, and it doesn't accept unsolicited submissions.

Global Music Rights, or GMR, licenses a catalog of more than 136,000 works for a smaller group of writers. Its public pages don't explain how a writer joins. For most independent songwriters, the real choice is BMI or ASCAP.

Which one should you join?

Neither pays a better rate on paper, because each pays by its own surveys and rules. Choose the one whose terms suit you. ASCAP's free combined writer and publisher signup is cheaper if you want your own publishing company. BMI's two-year terms are simple to track if you know your dates.

Whichever you pick, register every song, list every co-writer and keep your contact and payment details current.

How Traxure helps

Traxure doesn't join PROs or register songs for you. It watches your releases once they're out, which is what your streaming money depends on. It runs a full check of your catalog on 12 platforms every 24 hours, and alerts you when a release goes missing, when its details change, or when a release you didn't put out shows up on your profile. Plans start at $12 a month, and you can cancel anytime.

See plans

Questions artists ask

Is BMI or ASCAP better?

Neither is better for everyone. Both are free for songwriters and collect the same kind of royalties. Compare the publisher fees, how the contract ends and when each pays, then pick the one that fits.

Can I join both BMI and ASCAP?

Not as a writer. ASCAP says you can belong to only one society at a time as a writer for US performances. It also says you can be a publisher member at more than one society.

Is it free to join BMI or ASCAP?

Yes, for songwriters. BMI charges publishers a one-time $175 to $500. ASCAP charges $50 for a publisher-only membership and waives it when you join as writer and publisher together.

How do I switch from BMI to ASCAP?

End your BMI agreement with notice 3 to 6 months before your term ends, then join the new PRO. ASCAP says to contact your current society for what you need to switch. Going the other way, resign from ASCAP in your two-yearly window.

Do I need a publisher membership too?

If you haven't signed with a publisher, yes, if you want the publisher's half of performance royalties. ASCAP pays 50% to writers and 50% to publishers.

How do I join SESAC?

SESAC says it's invitation-only. The best route is for your lawyer, manager or agent to contact it for you, and it doesn't accept unsolicited submissions.

Sources

Traxure

Know the same day, not weeks later.

Traxure checks your releases on all 12 platforms every 24 hours, confirms a change before alerting you and tells you what to do next. Cancel anytime.

Pricing

Plans from $12 a month.

Monthly or yearly. Cancel anytime.

Early Black Friday: 25% off your first 3 months, or 40% off a first year. No code needed.

Get started