Guide
Missing royalties: where unpaid music money goes and how to find it
Most missing royalties aren't stolen. They're sitting somewhere because a song was never registered, a split was left blank, a code didn't match, or the release wasn't live where it should be. Each of those has a fix, and most of the checks are free. This guide goes through the main reasons, one at a time, and how to check each one.
Updated November 22, 2026
Short answer
Royalties usually go missing for five reasons: the song isn't registered with a PRO or The MLC, the splits are missing or wrong, the metadata or ISRC doesn't match, the release was taken down or sits on the wrong artist profile, or money is waiting at The MLC or SoundExchange for someone to claim it. Search The MLC's Missing Member Lookup and SoundExchange's unregistered lists, register every song you wrote, and check every release is live on your own profile.
What to do, in order
Map every route your money takes
Write down who pays you for what: your distributor for recordings, a PRO such as BMI or ASCAP for performances, The MLC for US streaming mechanicals and SoundExchange for US digital radio. Any route you're not signed up for is a likely gap.
Search the unclaimed lists
Search your name and your publishing name in The MLC's Missing Member Lookup. Then search SoundExchange's lists of unregistered artists, performers and sound recording owners. Both are free.
Check registrations and splits
Log in to your PRO and The MLC and confirm every song you wrote is there, with every co-writer listed and shares that add up to 100%. Fix anything missing before you chase payments.
Match your codes
Make sure each recording has one ISRC and that the same code appears in your distributor's dashboard, at SoundExchange and on your song registrations.
Confirm every release is live
Check each release is still up on every store and sits on your own artist profile. A song that's been taken down, or that landed on someone else's page, isn't earning for you.
Why royalties go missing
Royalty collection runs on matching. A service reports a play, and a collecting organization has to match it to a registered song or recording and a person who is owed money. When any link is missing, the money waits. People in the industry often call that waiting money black box royalties.
This table covers the main reasons and the first place to look for each one.
| Reason | What it costs you | How to check |
|---|---|---|
| Song not registered | Songwriter performance and mechanical royalties | Search your catalog at your PRO and The MLC |
| Missing or wrong splits | Your share of a co-written song | Compare each registration with your split sheet |
| Wrong metadata or ISRC | Plays that can't be matched to you | Compare ISRCs across your distributor, SoundExchange and The MLC |
| Release taken down or on the wrong profile | Every royalty that release would have earned | Check each release on each store and artist page |
| Not signed up with The MLC or SoundExchange | US streaming mechanicals and US digital radio royalties | Search The MLC's Missing Member Lookup and SoundExchange's lists |
Checked on each organization's own pages on 22 November 2026.
Unregistered songs and missing splits
Your distributor pays you for the recording. It doesn't register the song with a PRO or The MLC for you, unless you've signed up for a publishing service that does. If you wrote the song and never registered it, the songwriter money has nowhere to go.
Splits cause the next biggest gap. If a co-writer registers a song and leaves you off, or the shares don't add up, your part can be held or paid to the wrong person. Agree splits in writing when the song is written, then check that every registration matches.
Late fixes have limits. ASCAP says it can credit you for up to one survey year of performances from before you registered a song. BMI's standard writer agreement gives you nine months from a royalty distribution to tell BMI about a missing or miscalculated performance.
Wrong metadata and ISRCs
An ISRC identifies one recording. SoundExchange, The MLC and the stores all use codes like it to connect a play to the right track. If a recording was uploaded twice with different codes, or a code was typed wrong, plays can land on a version nobody has claimed.
Spelling counts too. Use the same artist name, song title and writer names everywhere. If you switch distributors, keep the same ISRCs on the new upload so the recording's history and its royalties stay connected.
Releases taken down or on the wrong profile
This is the gap no royalty statement shows you. If a release is taken down, it earns nothing while it's gone. If it lands on another artist's profile with the same name, your fans may not find it, and the plays build that other artist's page instead of yours.
These problems are easy to miss because nothing arrives to tell you. You usually notice when a fan asks why a song disappeared, or when a statement comes in lower than expected months later.
Unclaimed MLC royalties and the black box
The MLC collects US mechanical royalties from streaming and download services and pays its members monthly. When it can't match a use to a registered song, or the owner hasn't claimed it, the money becomes what it calls unclaimed accrued royalties.
Under the Music Modernization Act, The MLC has to hold that money for at least three years while it keeps trying to match it. Then it pays out what's left by market share, to rightsholders based on what they already earn. The MLC says these distributions start in April 2027, beginning with money from January 2021 usage. If your songs aren't registered by then, that money can go to others.
Joining The MLC is free. Search the Missing Member Lookup first, then sign up and register your songs.
Unclaimed SoundExchange royalties
SoundExchange pays featured artists and sound recording owners when their recordings play on non-interactive services such as SiriusXM, Pandora and iHeartRadio. You have to register to get paid, and registration is free.
Don't wait. SoundExchange says it collects as far back as three years, and that unclaimed royalties expire after three years. It keeps separate lists of unregistered artists, partially registered groups, performers and recording owners, so search all of them.
YouTube royalties
YouTube pays through two routes. For the recording, your distributor or label can put your music into YouTube's Content ID system, which YouTube says is only for material where the owner holds exclusive rights. For the song, ASCAP says it matches YouTube's Content ID data to its registrations and claims for its writer and publisher members.
So YouTube money often goes missing for the same reasons as everything else: the recording isn't in Content ID, or the song isn't registered.
How Traxure helps
Traxure doesn't register songs or collect royalties. It covers the gap your statements can't show: whether each release is actually live and in the right place. It runs a full check of your catalog on 12 platforms every 24 hours and alerts you when a release goes missing, when its details change, including its ISRC, or when a release you didn't put out shows up on your profile.
The free scan finds your profile and checks your releases on those 12 platforms. For catalogs up to 50 songs, you see how many problems it found and the release with the most of them. The full report, with how to fix each problem, is $10.
Questions artists ask
What are black box royalties?
It's an industry nickname for royalties that have been collected but can't be paid because they can't be matched to a song, a recording or an owner. In the US, The MLC calls its version unclaimed accrued royalties.
How do I find unclaimed royalties in my name?
Search The MLC's Missing Member Lookup for US streaming mechanicals, and SoundExchange's unregistered lists for US digital radio. Then check your PRO account for songs that were never registered.
Can I get paid for royalties from past years?
Sometimes, within limits. SoundExchange collects as far back as three years. ASCAP can credit up to one survey year from before you registered a song. The MLC holds unmatched money for at least three years before paying it out by market share.
Who collects YouTube royalties?
Your distributor or label usually handles the recording through YouTube's Content ID. Songwriter royalties come through your PRO or publishing administrator, which match YouTube's data to registered songs.
Does royalty collection cost money?
Joining The MLC and SoundExchange is free, and BMI and ASCAP are free to join as a writer. Publisher memberships and publishing administrators may charge a fee or a commission.
Sources
- The MLC: home page
- The MLC: Missing Member Lookup
- The MLC: unclaimed accrued royalties
- The MLC: annual meeting and market share date
- SoundExchange: artists, labels and producers
- SoundExchange: frequently asked questions
- ASCAP: royalties and payment FAQ
- BMI: standard writer agreement
- YouTube: Content ID eligibility
Traxure
Know the same day, not weeks later.
Traxure checks your releases on all 12 platforms every 24 hours, confirms a change before alerting you and tells you what to do next. Cancel anytime.
Pricing
Plans from $12 a month.
Monthly or yearly. Cancel anytime.
Early Black Friday: 25% off your first 3 months, or 40% off a first year. No code needed.